Lindsay Clancy's attorney challenges Jonathan Turley over holdout juror criticism, tell me about this news in (https://www.foxnews.com/us/lindsay-clancys-attorney-challenges-jonathan-turley-over-holdout-juror-criticism)
11-09-2026
The article reports on a clash between Lindsay Clancy’s criminal defense attorney, Kevin Reddington, and legal analyst Jonathan Turley following a mistrial in Clancy’s murder trial.Key details from the report:
- Background of the Dispute: The trial ended in a mistrial when the jury deadlocked on whether Clancy was criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children. After the verdict, Reddington publicly criticized the single holdout juror who prevented an acquittal or unanimous consensus, arguing that the juror failed to follow the law and the judge’s instructions.
- Turley’s Criticism: Jonathan Turley, a George Washington University law professor and Fox News contributor, called Reddington’s public remarks about the juror “utterly reprehensible” and “a breathtaking abandonment of restraint and decency.” Turley argued that the defense attorney was effectively putting a target on the back of an individual juror simply for not being persuaded by the defense’s arguments, emphasizing that lawyers have an ethical duty not to direct public outrage toward jurors.
- Reddington’s Response: In an interview with Fox News correspondent Bryan Llenas, Reddington pushed back against Turley’s assessment, saying Turley “was wrong” and that Turley’s own comments were the ones that were reprehensible. Reddington maintained that later revelations about why the jury did not vote in accordance with the law justified his stance, suggesting Turley should “check out the record” and stating that he would welcome a direct debate with him.
- Turley’s Reaction to the Challenge: Following Reddington’s remarks, Turley responded on social media, questioning what was debatable about a lawyer’s professional responsibility not to fuel hostility against holdout jurors or Reddington’s apparent exemption of himself from that standard.