Woman who pleaded guilty in Colorado elder fraud, romance scam case now accused of targeting other men, tell me about this news in (https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/other/woman-who-pleaded-guilty-in-colorado-elder-fraud-romance-scam-case-now-accused-of-targeting-other-men/ar-AA2cnyjp?ocid=BingNewsVerp)

Case Summary

Priscilla Johnson, 33, recently pleaded guilty to theft and criminal exploitation of an at-risk adult in Colorado’s 18th Judicial District for carrying out an in-person “romance scam” against an elderly widower. Following her plea, investigators uncovered evidence that she allegedly targeted multiple other men in the Denver metro area, with losses totaling hundreds of thousands of dollars.

The Initial Case

• The Setup: In July 2025, Johnson approached a 90-year-old widower at a King Soopers grocery store in Centennial, Colorado. She introduced herself using the alias “Elizabeth John” and claimed she had moved to the state after her fiancé was tragically killed in a car crash.

• The Scam: After establishing a romantic connection, Johnson claimed that her professional makeup kit had been stolen from her car and that she needed $6,000 to replace it for upcoming work. The victim gave her the cash. She later claimed she had cancer and needed $34,000 for medical treatments, which the victim also paid.

• The Break: When Johnson demanded an additional $40,000 claiming her cancer had spread to Los Angeles, the victim stated he needed to speak with his son. Johnson immediately told him to forget the money and cut off contact. The victim’s son contacted the Arapahoe County Sheriff’s Office, which identified Johnson through phone records and a photo lineup.

• The Plea Deal: Under the agreement, Johnson avoided prison time but was ordered to repay the full $40,000 plus interest to the victim and complete 60 hours of community service.

New Accusations and Potential Victims

While examining records tied to Johnson’s phone number, investigators discovered communication patterns suggesting the Centennial case was not isolated:

• An 80-Year-Old Victim: Another man reported meeting Johnson outside an Englewood grocery store. She used the identical story about a deceased fiancé and stolen makeup kits, ultimately obtaining around $7,500 under the guise of a loan backed by a promissory note before cutting contact.

• $450,000 Investment Scheme: Authorities linked Johnson’s number to communications with another man who reported losing approximately $450,000 in what began as a small, seemingly profitable investment opportunity that escalated over text and WhatsApp.

Local prosecutors and sheriff’s investigators continue to review evidence to determine the full scope of the operation and whether additional charges will be filed.