Judge temporarily blocks deportation of man shot by ICE agent in NYC's Marble Hill: news

Federal Judge Blocks Deportation of Man Shot by ICE Agent in NYC’s Marble Hill

A federal judge has temporarily blocked the deportation of Oscar Bergal, a 28-year-old Dominican national who was shot by an Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agent in the Marble Hill neighborhood of Upper Manhattan, New York City.

The emergency order prohibits federal authorities from removing Bergal from the United States and restricts immigration officials from transferring him outside the New York and New Jersey jurisdiction while legal proceedings remain underway.

Overview of the Marble Hill ICE Shooting Incident

The shooting occurred on October 8 during an attempted enforcement operation in Marble Hill. According to the New York City Police Department (NYPD), an ICE agent fired seven shots into a vehicle carrying Bergal and his 5-year-old child.

Bergal sustained a gunshot wound to the neck and was transported by NYPD officers to an area hospital for emergency treatment. His young child, seated in the back, was not physically injured. Following medical care, federal authorities took Bergal into custody and removed him from the hospital, prompting widespread protests and immediate legal challenges.

Legal Action and Temporary Restraining Order

In response to his detention, immigration attorneys filed an emergency habeas corpus petition in federal court seeking a temporary restraining order to prevent expedited removal.

• Judicial Injunction: U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken and U.S. District Judge John Cronan issued rulings barring the government from deporting Bergal and requiring federal representatives to confirm his current detention location and condition.

  www.washingtonsun.com

• Jurisdictional Boundary: The ruling mandates that Bergal cannot be moved outside the regional jurisdiction while his lawyers argue for his immediate release and access to proper medical care.

  CBC

• Due Process Claims: Legal defense teams argue that removing Bergal from the country or moving him across state jurisdictions undermines his constitutional due process rights and deprives him of necessary post-operative medical monitoring.

  Facebook

Community Reaction and Scrutiny Over Federal Enforcement

The Marble Hill shooting has drawn sharp condemnation from local New York City officials, civil rights advocates, and community leaders. Critics pointed out that the operation took place in a densely populated residential zone near schools during dismissal hours. While federal officials alleged the vehicle posed a threat during the apprehension, advocacy groups and defense attorneys continue to demand body camera disclosures, transparent oversight of federal agent conduct, and full accountability regarding ICE enforcement protocols in metropolitan communities.